Alice’s puppy-cuddling club could include a social norm against giving psychotic monkeys control over the economy. In fact, in every real-life example of this fallacy coming to mind, the puppy-cuddlers and the psychotic-monkey economy-Czarists are different factions who hate each other.
Maybe this applies in most cases? I don’t know, I’ve worked on making communities for puppy-cuddlers where I’ve thought they ended too psychotic-monkey-Czarist in the end. At the very least, it seems unfair to ignore the fact that a Blue coalition does exist, even if Bob is also overreacting in his accusations.
Alice’s puppy-cuddling club could include a social norm against giving psychotic monkeys control over the economy. In fact, in every real-life example of this fallacy coming to mind, the puppy-cuddlers and the psychotic-monkey economy-Czarists are different factions who hate each other.
Maybe this applies in most cases? I don’t know, I’ve worked on making communities for puppy-cuddlers where I’ve thought they ended too psychotic-monkey-Czarist in the end. At the very least, it seems unfair to ignore the fact that a Blue coalition does exist, even if Bob is also overreacting in his accusations.