Naw, Quirrell spent that minute in his snake form because it’s less vulnerable to Dementors, and when disaster struck he threw away his wand (recall how Harry got attacked through his wand) and assumed snake form again, probably as a last ditch defense. So I’m not sure if your final point supports your conclusion or mine.
And Harry was probably screaming just because he was scared.
ETA: I just realized another funny thing. As Quirrell is an unregistered Animagus and Bahry saw him transform, in the aftermath he’ll be going to Azkaban for two years unless something unusual happens.
ETA: I just realized another funny thing. As Quirrell is an unregistered Animagus and Bahry saw him transform, in the aftermath he’ll be going to Azkaban for two years unless something unusual happens.
“And then it was already too late” prompts in the text suggest that Quirrell died (and probably won’t revive himself as Quirrell again).
Edit: This seems to be an inference from incorrect assumption, correction here.
The most direct interpretation of “it was too late” is that Harry’s Patronus was down long enough for the Dementors to find them and see Bellatrix had escaped.
The fear of dementors isn’t Quirrel’s problem, it’s that his spell and Harry’s touched. He threw away his wand to stop the magical cascade, and Harry was screaming because he felt the same thing, but didn’t understand it as quickly as Quirrel did.
Note that on Quirrell’s “Evil Overlord List”, Rule 34 (“I will not turn into a snake. It never helps.”) has been replaced by (translated from Parseltongue) “Become Animaguss. All ssensible people do, if can. Thuss, very rare.” (Per chapter 49)
Note that on Quirrell’s “Evil Overlord List”, Rule 34 (“I will not turn into a snake. It never helps.”) has been replaced by (translated from Parseltongue) “Become Animaguss. All ssensible people do, if can. Thuss, very rare.” (Per chapter 49)
I don’t know why he turned back into a snake; others have suggested he’s less susceptible to Dementor influence in that case. It is also possible that his alternate form was some kind of magic done to his snake form, and that he simply reverted to snake form on losing control of whatever was producing his fake human form.
That throwing away the wand is helpful was suggested by the previous incident with the dementors and Harry’s wand.
Actually, it’s possible that 1) he needed to throw the wand away to stop the cascade, but 2) became a snake to avoid any Dementor influence happening by way of the wand. He may also have felt that Bellatrix would be less likely to kill Voldemort’s favorite snake than some random human tool/servant of his.
I don’t see this interpretation as plausible, too much implied drama for such an insignificant event in context (as more evidence, “last seconds tickling away” is a death metaphor). Dementors alerting Aurors about the escape is just the last nail in the coffin.
No, it’s the last seconds ticking away for a successful escape attempt- if Harry had put up his Patronus, there might have been time for Quirrell to recover, use a Memory Charm on the Auror, and abscond with BB without raising the alarm.
I now see that as more plausible than originally (having learned that my interpretation is not obvious to others), but remain uncertain and favoring the hypothesis of Quirrell having died. We’ll see what was actually intended.
...and if I replace my previous assumption that Quirrell collapsed as a direct result of Dementor influence that was opened by disappearance of Potter’s Patronus, with the much more plausible assumption that he collapsed because of magic incompatibility with Potter’s Patronus of the same nature as what killed him the first time, and only additionally suffered from Dementors, then it doesn’t follow that Dementors cause overwhelming harm, and so that prolonged exposure leads to death. This also explains throwing away the wand: make own magic weaker to reduce the effect of magical incompatibility.
Thus, now the hypothesis that Quirrell died seems less plausible than the alternative.
Really? I think it suggested that it was now too late for Dark Lord Harry to return to being Good Lad Harry without external intervention, a la kiss. He’s in too dark a place to think Happy Thoughts.
Naw, Quirrell spent that minute in his snake form because it’s less vulnerable to Dementors, and when disaster struck he threw away his wand (recall how Harry got attacked through his wand) and assumed snake form again, probably as a last ditch defense. So I’m not sure if your final point supports your conclusion or mine.
And Harry was probably screaming just because he was scared.
ETA: I just realized another funny thing. As Quirrell is an unregistered Animagus and Bahry saw him transform, in the aftermath he’ll be going to Azkaban for two years unless something unusual happens.
I have very little, if any, idea of what something “usual” would look like under these circumstances.
Polyjuiced Quirrell, mind you.
“And then it was already too late” prompts in the text suggest that Quirrell died (and probably won’t revive himself as Quirrell again).
Edit: This seems to be an inference from incorrect assumption, correction here.
The most direct interpretation of “it was too late” is that Harry’s Patronus was down long enough for the Dementors to find them and see Bellatrix had escaped.
Probably. And with the Aurors coming, Harry won’t have the chance to recast his Patronus before they all find him and give him a good talking-to.
Prediction in rot13: Bs pbhefr, jura gurl neevir, gurer jvyy or rvtug yrffre cngebav xrrcvat gur srne bs qrngu bss Dhveeryy. Vs gur fghaavat fcryy unf jbea bss, naq gur snpg gung ur guerj njnl uvf jnaq naq ghearq vagb n fanxr zrnaf gur qrzragbef ner uvf ceboyrz, abg gur pynfu jvgu Uneel’f zntvp, V cerqvpg fbzr irel vagrerfgvat guvatf jvyy unccra. Zbfgyl rcvp cjantr. Rvtug vf rabhtu, evtug?
The fear of dementors isn’t Quirrel’s problem, it’s that his spell and Harry’s touched. He threw away his wand to stop the magical cascade, and Harry was screaming because he felt the same thing, but didn’t understand it as quickly as Quirrel did.
Does that also explain why he turned back into a snake? I must have missed where that and throwing away a wand can help with a magical cascade.
It will be aesthetically unsatisfying if turning into a snake helps.
Note that on Quirrell’s “Evil Overlord List”, Rule 34 (“I will not turn into a snake. It never helps.”) has been replaced by (translated from Parseltongue) “Become Animaguss. All ssensible people do, if can. Thuss, very rare.” (Per chapter 49)
Or, “I will turn into a snake. It always helps.”
It’s a weird coincidence that the rule would have number 34.
Well, there are more than 33 rules. It’s not a particularly weird coincidence.
Not weird, perhaps, but rule 34 on Quirrel’s snake form is certainly creepy.
I don’t know why he turned back into a snake; others have suggested he’s less susceptible to Dementor influence in that case. It is also possible that his alternate form was some kind of magic done to his snake form, and that he simply reverted to snake form on losing control of whatever was producing his fake human form.
That throwing away the wand is helpful was suggested by the previous incident with the dementors and Harry’s wand.
Actually, it’s possible that 1) he needed to throw the wand away to stop the cascade, but 2) became a snake to avoid any Dementor influence happening by way of the wand. He may also have felt that Bellatrix would be less likely to kill Voldemort’s favorite snake than some random human tool/servant of his.
Snakes are easier to carry, for example.
More energy efficient. Less hygiene requirements.
I don’t see this interpretation as plausible, too much implied drama for such an insignificant event in context (as more evidence, “last seconds tickling away” is a death metaphor). Dementors alerting Aurors about the escape is just the last nail in the coffin.
No, it’s the last seconds ticking away for a successful escape attempt- if Harry had put up his Patronus, there might have been time for Quirrell to recover, use a Memory Charm on the Auror, and abscond with BB without raising the alarm.
I now see that as more plausible than originally (having learned that my interpretation is not obvious to others), but remain uncertain and favoring the hypothesis of Quirrell having died. We’ll see what was actually intended.
...and if I replace my previous assumption that Quirrell collapsed as a direct result of Dementor influence that was opened by disappearance of Potter’s Patronus, with the much more plausible assumption that he collapsed because of magic incompatibility with Potter’s Patronus of the same nature as what killed him the first time, and only additionally suffered from Dementors, then it doesn’t follow that Dementors cause overwhelming harm, and so that prolonged exposure leads to death. This also explains throwing away the wand: make own magic weaker to reduce the effect of magical incompatibility.
Thus, now the hypothesis that Quirrell died seems less plausible than the alternative.
Really? I think it suggested that it was now too late for Dark Lord Harry to return to being Good Lad Harry without external intervention, a la kiss. He’s in too dark a place to think Happy Thoughts.
I read it as too late for Harry to save himself. And before that, Voldy was already gone, prior to Bahry’s reflexive stunner spell.