I agree that we can’t reasonably assume that the Patronus teleport, magical feedback and subsequent Dementor exposure had been part of Quirrell’s plan.
However, the much more limited and much more certain prediction that AK’ing a guard Auror while in Harry’s earshot would cause a mess and make the stated “perfect crime” plan impossible is easily within Quirrell’s ability to figure out beforehand, even on the spot.
Therefore, his casting of AK—if not the very unusual result—is sufficient evidence that the “perfect crime” plan was at least to some degree horsecrap. Not that he must have wanted Harry to get caught, but, unless he had a doppelganger of Bahry in his pocket to replace him with, he certainly wasn’t as interested in a clean breakout as he had claimed.
I agree. The exact disastrous consequences of Harry’s reaction were most likely not part of the plan, and can’t be seen as a serious flaw or rationalized-in-hindsight as having been part of the plan all along.
I agree that we can’t reasonably assume that the Patronus teleport, magical feedback and subsequent Dementor exposure had been part of Quirrell’s plan.
However, the much more limited and much more certain prediction that AK’ing a guard Auror while in Harry’s earshot would cause a mess and make the stated “perfect crime” plan impossible is easily within Quirrell’s ability to figure out beforehand, even on the spot.
Therefore, his casting of AK—if not the very unusual result—is sufficient evidence that the “perfect crime” plan was at least to some degree horsecrap. Not that he must have wanted Harry to get caught, but, unless he had a doppelganger of Bahry in his pocket to replace him with, he certainly wasn’t as interested in a clean breakout as he had claimed.
I agree. The exact disastrous consequences of Harry’s reaction were most likely not part of the plan, and can’t be seen as a serious flaw or rationalized-in-hindsight as having been part of the plan all along.