I personally read “in the style of Spock” as “what would Spock say if writing the review after watching the movie.” Even if the query were “write what Spock would say,” I’d interpret it as implicit that he watched the movie first.
Yeah. An even more obvious example would be something like “what would Spock say if reviewing ‘Warp Drives for Dummies’”. In that case, it seems pretty clear that the author is expected to invent some “hallucinatory” content for the book, and not output something like “I don’t know that one”.
The actual examples can be interpreted similarly; the author should assume that the movie/book exists in the hypothetical counterfactual world they are asked to generate content from.
I personally read “in the style of Spock” as “what would Spock say if writing the review after watching the movie.” Even if the query were “write what Spock would say,” I’d interpret it as implicit that he watched the movie first.
Yeah. An even more obvious example would be something like “what would Spock say if reviewing ‘Warp Drives for Dummies’”. In that case, it seems pretty clear that the author is expected to invent some “hallucinatory” content for the book, and not output something like “I don’t know that one”.
The actual examples can be interpreted similarly; the author should assume that the movie/book exists in the hypothetical counterfactual world they are asked to generate content from.