My “straw-man” does appear to have defenders, though we seem to agree you aren’t one of them.
To some extent I am one such defender in the sense that I probably expect there to be a lot more of something like rationality to our values than you do. I was just saying that it’s not necessary for that to be the case. Either way the important thing is that values are in the territory where you can use rationality on them.
The point at which I think rationality enters our values is when those values are self-modifying, at which point you must provide a function for updating. Perhaps we only differ on the percentage we believe to be self-modifying.
To some extent I am one such defender in the sense that I probably expect there to be a lot more of something like rationality to our values than you do. I was just saying that it’s not necessary for that to be the case. Either way the important thing is that values are in the territory where you can use rationality on them.
For reference, this point was discussed in this post:
The point at which I think rationality enters our values is when those values are self-modifying, at which point you must provide a function for updating. Perhaps we only differ on the percentage we believe to be self-modifying.