P/S/A: exercise can not make you healthy if your diet is poor.
If your diet is micronutrient poor because you are living off prepackaged or fast foods, milk (whole), bananas, and orange juice is a good/cheap/easy place to start. Replace sugar water/other empty carb sources with these.
Hmm. I used to drink orange juice but I stopped because I was concerned that it was too much sugar and not enough fiber or something relative to eating fruit. Would you recommend drinking orange juice over, say, eating oranges?
no, it’s just that orange juice is an easy transition for someone who has been drinking soda. You can even mix with sparkling water if you have a real soda addiction.
I consider orange juice and other prepackaged juices to be, basically, sugar water. I wouldn’t recommend switching to juices because you’re still drinking your empty calories and throwing sugar bombs at your body under the illusion that it’s “healthy”.
100% OJ is not most prepackaged juice. It is very high in many of the water soluble vitamins as well as potassium and some magnesium. That it is healthy is only an “illusion” if you’re drinking way too much of it.
Soda water. No calories, but still has the carbonation. I was never really addicted to soda, and didn’t have trouble switching to water personally, but whenever I drink soda water my mind associates the carbonation with soda, and releases happy chemicals anyway.
This won’t work for everyone, because a lot of people find the lack of sugar really unsettling with carbonation, and don’t like soda water. But, I’d expect it to work pretty well for those who it does work for.
Is there any particular reason you want to get your calories and nutrition in liquid form? If you actually do, there’s a large variety of smoothies and such that you can make.
People “addicted” to soda are actually “addicted” to the sugar rush (usually enhanced by a bit of caffeine). Subject to all the usual caveats about people not being all the same, I don’t think that a habit of regularly consuming a fair chunk of glucose and fructose in a rapidly-absorbed form is good for one’s health.
yeah, everyone with a crappy diet gets told to drink water instead of soda, guess how often that actually works?
In the interim of cutting down empty calorie intake, replacing those sources of sugar with milk, OJ, and bananas is much more practicable advice than drink water.
Unless you have had extensive practical experience of actually dealing with real people who attempted to replace soda with water and with real people who attempted to replace soda with juices, I have to doubt your opinion on what’s “practicable” and what’s not.
Oh, and everyone with a crappy diet gets told to improve it. Guess how often that actually works?
I was never a real soda person, but I used to drink mostly juices, and now drink almost entirely water. I didn’t even find it particularly difficult, and it was a big part of how I lost a significant amount of weight. There’s a huge amount of calories in there, and I can get more enjoyment from eating half as many as I used to from drinking them.
P/S/A: exercise can not make you healthy if your diet is poor.
If your diet is micronutrient poor because you are living off prepackaged or fast foods, milk (whole), bananas, and orange juice is a good/cheap/easy place to start. Replace sugar water/other empty carb sources with these.
Hmm. I used to drink orange juice but I stopped because I was concerned that it was too much sugar and not enough fiber or something relative to eating fruit. Would you recommend drinking orange juice over, say, eating oranges?
no, it’s just that orange juice is an easy transition for someone who has been drinking soda. You can even mix with sparkling water if you have a real soda addiction.
I consider orange juice and other prepackaged juices to be, basically, sugar water. I wouldn’t recommend switching to juices because you’re still drinking your empty calories and throwing sugar bombs at your body under the illusion that it’s “healthy”.
100% OJ is not most prepackaged juice. It is very high in many of the water soluble vitamins as well as potassium and some magnesium. That it is healthy is only an “illusion” if you’re drinking way too much of it.
Data: http://nutritiondata.self.com/facts/fruits-and-fruit-juices/1973/2
I see a great deal of sugar and noticeable amounts of vitamin C. That’s pretty much it. Sorry, in my book that counts as an empty-calorie sugar bomb.
I am not arguing that soda is better, but if you’re taking the trouble of switching, there are better options available.
Please name them?
Soda water. No calories, but still has the carbonation. I was never really addicted to soda, and didn’t have trouble switching to water personally, but whenever I drink soda water my mind associates the carbonation with soda, and releases happy chemicals anyway.
This won’t work for everyone, because a lot of people find the lack of sugar really unsettling with carbonation, and don’t like soda water. But, I’d expect it to work pretty well for those who it does work for.
Water.
Is there any particular reason you want to get your calories and nutrition in liquid form? If you actually do, there’s a large variety of smoothies and such that you can make.
People “addicted” to soda are actually “addicted” to the sugar rush (usually enhanced by a bit of caffeine). Subject to all the usual caveats about people not being all the same, I don’t think that a habit of regularly consuming a fair chunk of glucose and fructose in a rapidly-absorbed form is good for one’s health.
yeah, everyone with a crappy diet gets told to drink water instead of soda, guess how often that actually works? In the interim of cutting down empty calorie intake, replacing those sources of sugar with milk, OJ, and bananas is much more practicable advice than drink water.
Unless you have had extensive practical experience of actually dealing with real people who attempted to replace soda with water and with real people who attempted to replace soda with juices, I have to doubt your opinion on what’s “practicable” and what’s not.
Oh, and everyone with a crappy diet gets told to improve it. Guess how often that actually works?
I was never a real soda person, but I used to drink mostly juices, and now drink almost entirely water. I didn’t even find it particularly difficult, and it was a big part of how I lost a significant amount of weight. There’s a huge amount of calories in there, and I can get more enjoyment from eating half as many as I used to from drinking them.
I would recommend eating oranges over drinking orange juice.