Okay, okay, I’ll use singular they if you all promise that the first time someone pompously chides me for using “they” in the singular, you’ll give them at least as much trouble as you’re giving me for using gender-neutral third person pronouns.
Indeed I shall so chide. It’s not so much that “ey” and the like bother me, it’s mostly that Less Wrong might become one of the first communities where people can use singular they without flinching due to vague anticipation of undue contempt. Such trivial inconveniences add up very quickly for a certain kind of mind, like mine.
Question for the formally qualified grammarian: When using singular “they”, which is correct?
“When a person is biased, they make mistakes”
“When a person is based, they makes mistakes”
The second sounds absolutely horrible, but if singular “they” is really being used as a singular in the same sense as “he” or “she”, it sounds like it ought to be correct.
Have a gander at Language Log where the “singular they” has been extensively discussed—mostly, apparently, because it’s something of a litmus test to determine whether someone is a descriptivist or a prescriptivist grammarian; the LL crowd falling squarely in the descriptivist camp.
The short answer is that it’s grammatically plural; it’s a “plural of indeterminacy of number” primarily, and has taken on under social pressure an aspect of “plural of indeterminacy of gender”. Number one is correct.
Okay, okay, I’ll use singular they if you all promise that the first time someone pompously chides me for using “they” in the singular, you’ll give them at least as much trouble as you’re giving me for using gender-neutral third person pronouns.
Indeed I shall so chide. It’s not so much that “ey” and the like bother me, it’s mostly that Less Wrong might become one of the first communities where people can use singular they without flinching due to vague anticipation of undue contempt. Such trivial inconveniences add up very quickly for a certain kind of mind, like mine.
Well, I don’t anticipate undue contempt when using the singular they on Language Log, either. :-)
Deal. I’ll even pull rank with my formal qualifications on English grammar, should they care about that.
Question for the formally qualified grammarian: When using singular “they”, which is correct?
“When a person is biased, they make mistakes”
“When a person is based, they makes mistakes”
The second sounds absolutely horrible, but if singular “they” is really being used as a singular in the same sense as “he” or “she”, it sounds like it ought to be correct.
Consider:
When you, Yvain, are biased, you make mistakes
Clearly in the 2nd person singular, the verb displays “plural” agreement. It’s the same for “they”.
Have a gander at Language Log where the “singular they” has been extensively discussed—mostly, apparently, because it’s something of a litmus test to determine whether someone is a descriptivist or a prescriptivist grammarian; the LL crowd falling squarely in the descriptivist camp.
The short answer is that it’s grammatically plural; it’s a “plural of indeterminacy of number” primarily, and has taken on under social pressure an aspect of “plural of indeterminacy of gender”. Number one is correct.
ETA: background info.
I like singular they, but I also think ze is better than ey because it looks less like a cut-off other word