IIRC, a well-cast Imperius can be very convincing. I don’t think it’s likely though, considering H&C’s apparent incompetence.
That’s not to say other characters we know aren’t already under the Imperius. It seems like a spell that would be used often than in cannon if no one is holding any idiot balls.
If that were so, then it would have made detecting Imperiused infiltrators during the war trivial: just floo everyone in the Ministry through a room in Hogwarts, with in- and out-fireplaces, and arrest any who set off the wards. You could do it once a week, or every morning, or randomly thrice a week, or whatever. It’s too obvious, and too easy and non-controversial, for someone like Dumbledore not to have noticed and put in place. This did not happen.
The ministry was clearly not actually trying to catch Death Eaters during the first war. Even simpler than this (as a first pass to catch spies) would be to make all ministry employees roll up their left sleeve on a regular basis.
Was I truly the only person who read that and thought that it would make a hell of a lot more sense for the Death Eaters to control whether or not the Mark was visible? Why does everyone persist in assuming that it is permanently visible, rather considering the possibility that Voldemort wasn’t quite that stupid, especially in MoR?
Perhaps casting Imperius is detected by Hogwarts wards. This is in fact more likely (that is, it better fits my impression of what wards should be like) than supposing that Hogwarts wards detect ongoing Imperius enchantments.
‘ongoing’ doesn’t seem to be the germane distinction. For example, in canon book 7, don’t the Gringotts wards and mechanisms detect both ongoing polymorph and an Imperius when Harry et al break in?
Goblins have a history of taking certain things very seriously, and security is one of them. The Ministry is very serious about looking like they take security seriously. The difference is not a small one.
Correct! You can’t apparate into or out of Hogwarts. The ancient wards on the school have prevented this since its founding. The Floo network, on the other hand, works just fine, as has been demonstrated several times in HP:MoR and in canon. The Hogwarts wards can also be easily bypassed by the vanishing cabinet, phoenix teleportation, or portkeys. In HP:MoR, the use of portkeys can be blocked by wards like the ones on Azkaban (and presumably a handful of other ultra-high-security places, like Nurmengard).
While we’re on the subject of easily-exploitable security holes, Harry J. P. E. Verres might find these interesting:
House-elf apparition uses a different mechanism that effortlessly bypasses anti-apparition jinxes, such as (canonically) the ones in the Malfoy manor’s cellar-cum-dungeon.
If it’s possible to make small portable portkeys that can be activated on a whim, as Quirrell and Santa Claus have both shown themselves able to do, then this offers an excellent escape method from areas under anti-apparition jinxes, and Harry should definitely carry one at all times. Having such a panic button available could save his life. Unauthorized portkeys are very illegal, but this does not seem to be effectively enforced.
Easy, secure information transmission is possible by using the protean charm to link small items together. This is apparently a fairly difficult charm, but it may well be just a matter of skill, and therefore something that a sufficiently determined young genius can learn quickly. This is faster than using a Patronus to carry messages, less conspicuous, and can be used to broadcast information. Canonically, this was used by people on both sides of the Second Wizarding War.
See above. Quirrel wouldn’t have made the slip that alerted the readers to a Groundhog Day Attack.
Now, the imperius… I could believe a confundus, maybe. She’s not mindless enough for an imperius.
I don’t know, Canon!Harry was the only one in his class who could resist it if I recall. And that was in their fourth year.
I think linkhyrule5 means that she isn’t acting mindless enough for an Imperius.
IIRC, a well-cast Imperius can be very convincing. I don’t think it’s likely though, considering H&C’s apparent incompetence.
That’s not to say other characters we know aren’t already under the Imperius. It seems like a spell that would be used often than in cannon if no one is holding any idiot balls.
Perhaps Imperius is one of the charms detected by Hogwart’s wards.
If that were so, then it would have made detecting Imperiused infiltrators during the war trivial: just floo everyone in the Ministry through a room in Hogwarts, with in- and out-fireplaces, and arrest any who set off the wards. You could do it once a week, or every morning, or randomly thrice a week, or whatever. It’s too obvious, and too easy and non-controversial, for someone like Dumbledore not to have noticed and put in place. This did not happen.
The ministry was clearly not actually trying to catch Death Eaters during the first war. Even simpler than this (as a first pass to catch spies) would be to make all ministry employees roll up their left sleeve on a regular basis.
Was I truly the only person who read that and thought that it would make a hell of a lot more sense for the Death Eaters to control whether or not the Mark was visible? Why does everyone persist in assuming that it is permanently visible, rather considering the possibility that Voldemort wasn’t quite that stupid, especially in MoR?
Perhaps casting Imperius is detected by Hogwarts wards. This is in fact more likely (that is, it better fits my impression of what wards should be like) than supposing that Hogwarts wards detect ongoing Imperius enchantments.
‘ongoing’ doesn’t seem to be the germane distinction. For example, in canon book 7, don’t the Gringotts wards and mechanisms detect both ongoing polymorph and an Imperius when Harry et al break in?
No, the Imperius was cast inside the bank.
If that were valid here, then wouldn’t Gringotts be the place to send Ministry employees at random thrice a week?
Yup. Why does Gringotts have better and useful wards than the Ministry? Because they’re all idiots.
Goblins have a history of taking certain things very seriously, and security is one of them. The Ministry is very serious about looking like they take security seriously. The difference is not a small one.
You could’t apparate to Hogward in cannon, if I recall correctly?
Correct! You can’t apparate into or out of Hogwarts. The ancient wards on the school have prevented this since its founding. The Floo network, on the other hand, works just fine, as has been demonstrated several times in HP:MoR and in canon. The Hogwarts wards can also be easily bypassed by the vanishing cabinet, phoenix teleportation, or portkeys. In HP:MoR, the use of portkeys can be blocked by wards like the ones on Azkaban (and presumably a handful of other ultra-high-security places, like Nurmengard).
While we’re on the subject of easily-exploitable security holes, Harry J. P. E. Verres might find these interesting:
House-elf apparition uses a different mechanism that effortlessly bypasses anti-apparition jinxes, such as (canonically) the ones in the Malfoy manor’s cellar-cum-dungeon.
If it’s possible to make small portable portkeys that can be activated on a whim, as Quirrell and Santa Claus have both shown themselves able to do, then this offers an excellent escape method from areas under anti-apparition jinxes, and Harry should definitely carry one at all times. Having such a panic button available could save his life. Unauthorized portkeys are very illegal, but this does not seem to be effectively enforced.
Easy, secure information transmission is possible by using the protean charm to link small items together. This is apparently a fairly difficult charm, but it may well be just a matter of skill, and therefore something that a sufficiently determined young genius can learn quickly. This is faster than using a Patronus to carry messages, less conspicuous, and can be used to broadcast information. Canonically, this was used by people on both sides of the Second Wizarding War.