I think Germany is an extreme outlier here fwiw, (eg) Japan did far worse things and after WW2 cared more about covering up wrongdoing than with admitting fault; further, Germany’s government and cultural “reformation” was very much strongarmed by the US and other allies, whereas the US actively assisted Japan in covering up war crimes.
I started writing a comment reply to elaborate after getting some disagreevotes on the parent comment, but decided that it’d be a distraction from the main conversation; I might expand on my position in an LW shortform at some point in the near future.
I think Germany is an extreme outlier here fwiw, (eg) Japan did far worse things and after WW2 cared more about covering up wrongdoing than with admitting fault; further, Germany’s government and cultural “reformation” was very much strongarmed by the US and other allies, whereas the US actively assisted Japan in covering up war crimes.
EDIT: See shortform elaboration: https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/s58hDHX2GkFDbpGKD/linch-s-shortform?commentId=ywf8R3CobzdkbTx3d
Here are some notes on why I think Imperial Japan was unusually bad, even by the very low bar set by the Second World War.
Curious why you say “far worse” rather than “similarly bad” though this isn’t important to the main conversation.
I started writing a comment reply to elaborate after getting some disagreevotes on the parent comment, but decided that it’d be a distraction from the main conversation; I might expand on my position in an LW shortform at some point in the near future.
Update: OK, now I agree. I encourage you to make a post on it.