Didn’t Will_Newsome say several times that he was trolling and post material designed to get downvoted? Not sure that’s quite a comparison to eridu.
(To give a recent example, we banned a user from #lesswrong for mailbombing with porn sites another user; they did this partially because they were offended and partially to get themselves banned and stop spending time there. The ban is perfectly justified, yet I would not have called them a troll before or after.)
Didn’t Will_Newsome say several times that he was trolling and post material designed to get downvoted? Not sure that’s quite a comparison to eridu.
Yes, he did. No, I wasn’t comparing them to each other, but it is the case that unlike eridu or Dmytry, Will_Newsome did not trigger the “since he posted lots of trollish comments, let’s delete reasonable comments by him as well” reaction in the mods, as far as I can remember.
I’ve had a few comments deleted that I thought weren’t egregiously unreasonable but were “provocative” and minimally substantive. I don’t think the deletions were too unreasonable either—perhaps a tad overzealous. Overall I think the LW mods have been quite just regarding me, though some of the normal users have been a bit crazy, and I’m glad those users aren’t mods.
Didn’t Will_Newsome say several times that he was trolling and post material designed to get downvoted? Not sure that’s quite a comparison to eridu.
(To give a recent example, we banned a user from
#lesswrong
for mailbombing with porn sites another user; they did this partially because they were offended and partially to get themselves banned and stop spending time there. The ban is perfectly justified, yet I would not have called them a troll before or after.)Yes, he did. No, I wasn’t comparing them to each other, but it is the case that unlike eridu or Dmytry, Will_Newsome did not trigger the “since he posted lots of trollish comments, let’s delete reasonable comments by him as well” reaction in the mods, as far as I can remember.
I’ve had a few comments deleted that I thought weren’t egregiously unreasonable but were “provocative” and minimally substantive. I don’t think the deletions were too unreasonable either—perhaps a tad overzealous. Overall I think the LW mods have been quite just regarding me, though some of the normal users have been a bit crazy, and I’m glad those users aren’t mods.