Explain what you mean? What are you calling the orthogonality thesis (note that part of my point is that different alleged versions of it don’t seem to be related), what are you calling “E. Yudkowsky’s argument”, and how does the orthogonality thesis shoot it down?
Ah I see, you are talking about the “meaning of life” document. Yes, the version of the orthogonality thesis that says that goals are not specified by intelligence (notand also the version presented in Eliezer’s tweet) does shoot down that document. (My comment was about that tweet, so was largely unrelated to that document).
I think the orthogonality thesis holds strongly enough to shoot down E. Yudkowsky’s argument?
Explain what you mean? What are you calling the orthogonality thesis (note that part of my point is that different alleged versions of it don’t seem to be related), what are you calling “E. Yudkowsky’s argument”, and how does the orthogonality thesis shoot it down?Ah I see, you are talking about the “meaning of life” document. Yes, the version of the orthogonality thesis that says that goals are not specified by intelligence (
notand also the version presented in Eliezer’s tweet) does shoot down that document. (My comment was about that tweet, so was largely unrelated to that document).