“Contrast that with this world (all numbers in real terms):
Time period 1: A makes $1, B makes $6, C makes $10.
Time period 2: A makes $10, B makes $5, C makes $9.
The median change in income is negative, two out of three people saw their wages decline. Do you think this means the economy got worse?”
I’m not sure I’m following your overall points in this section, but I’d certainly expect people to vote like they believed the economy got worse in such a situation.
“QC: the water usage argument against LLMs is extremely bad faith...”
Rule of thumb, if you’re reading some article and the water usage is measured in gallons, it’s bullsh*t. This isn’t even that, ml, seriously?! My very normal suburban house water bill doesn’t even measure in gallons, it measures in hundreds of cubic feet (at about $5/per hundred cubic feet). People do not realize how vast the quantities of water humans regularly divert and move around are (and how very little of it is required to directly sustain human life).