Disagree with the sociological claim because the Blanchardian arguments for the empirical claim are baaaaaaaad and it’s pretty reasonable to not credit an empirical claim when the arguments presented for it are so bad.
One could still defend the sociological claim due to the philosophical claim but at the same time I have the impression that there’s some hestitance partly because they are so confused about the arguments around the empirical claim.
Disagree with the sociological claim because the Blanchardian arguments for the empirical claim are baaaaaaaad and it’s pretty reasonable to not credit an empirical claim when the arguments presented for it are so bad.
One could still defend the sociological claim due to the philosophical claim but at the same time I have the impression that there’s some hestitance partly because they are so confused about the arguments around the empirical claim.