Gnargh. Of course someone has a counterexample. But I don’t think that is the typical lw AGI warning scenario. However, this could become a “no true Scotsman” discussion...
You mean like Gwern’s It Looks Like You’re Trying To Take Over The World? I think that made a good short story. Though I don’t think it would make a good movie, since there’s little in the way of cool visuals.
Greg Egan’s Crystal Nights is also more similar to the usual way things are imagined, though uhznavgl vf fnirq ol gur hayvxryl qrhf rk znpuvan bs vg orvat rnfvre sbe gur fvzhyngrq pvivyvmngvba gb znxr n cbpxrg qvzrafvba guna gnxr bire gur jbeyq.
Edit: There are also likely tons more such books written by Ted Chiang, Vernor Vinge, Greg Egan, and others, which I haven’t read yet so can’t list with confidence and without spoilers to myself.
Thanks for the list! Yes, it is possible to imagine stories that involve a superintelligence.
I could not imagine a movie/successful story where everybody is killed by an AGI within seconds because it has prepared that in secrecy and nobody realized it, and nobody could do anything about it. Seems like lacking a happy end and even a story.
However, I am glad to be corrected, and will check the links, the stories will surely be interesting!
Minor corrections: “Crystal Nights” does not have an H in the first word and is by Greg Egan. (The linked copy is on his own website, in fact, which also includes a number of his other works.)
Gnargh. Of course someone has a counterexample. But I don’t think that is the typical lw AGI warning scenario. However, this could become a “no true Scotsman” discussion...
You mean like Gwern’s It Looks Like You’re Trying To Take Over The World? I think that made a good short story. Though I don’t think it would make a good movie, since there’s little in the way of cool visuals.
Greg Egan’s Crystal Nights is also more similar to the usual way things are imagined, though uhznavgl vf fnirq ol gur hayvxryl qrhf rk znpuvan bs vg orvat rnfvre sbe gur fvzhyngrq pvivyvmngvba gb znxr n cbpxrg qvzrafvba guna gnxr bire gur jbeyq.
Crystal Nights is also very similar to Eliezer’s That Alien Message / Alicorn’s Starwink.
Edit: There are also likely tons more such books written by Ted Chiang, Vernor Vinge, Greg Egan, and others, which I haven’t read yet so can’t list with confidence and without spoilers to myself.
Thanks for the list! Yes, it is possible to imagine stories that involve a superintelligence.
I could not imagine a movie/successful story where everybody is killed by an AGI within seconds because it has prepared that in secrecy and nobody realized it, and nobody could do anything about it. Seems like lacking a happy end and even a story.
However, I am glad to be corrected, and will check the links, the stories will surely be interesting!
Minor corrections: “Crystal Nights” does not have an H in the first word and is by Greg Egan. (The linked copy is on his own website, in fact, which also includes a number of his other works.)
Thanks! I remember consciously thinking both those things, but somehow did the opposite of that.