As best I understood it, the point was that one’s belief in one’s own goodness is a source of drive—and if that goodness is false, the drive is misaimed, and the greater drive makes for greater ill consequences.
I think we agree that belief in one’s own goodness has the capability to go quite wrong, in such cases as the quote describes more wrong than an all-other-things-being-equal belief in one’s own evil. Where we seem to disagree is on the inevitability of this failure mode—I acknowledge that the failure mode exists and we should be cautious about it (although that may not have come across), whereas you seem to be implying that the failure mode is so prevalent that it would be better not to try to be a good overlord at all.
Partially. Yes, I would assert that the failure mode you’re talking about is prevalent (and point to a LOT of history to support that assertion; no one is evil is his own story). However the main point in the quote we’re talking about isn’t quite that, I think. Instead, consider such concepts as “autonomy”, “individuality”, and “diversity”.
As best I understood it, the point was that one’s belief in one’s own goodness is a source of drive—and if that goodness is false, the drive is misaimed, and the greater drive makes for greater ill consequences.
I think we agree that belief in one’s own goodness has the capability to go quite wrong, in such cases as the quote describes more wrong than an all-other-things-being-equal belief in one’s own evil. Where we seem to disagree is on the inevitability of this failure mode—I acknowledge that the failure mode exists and we should be cautious about it (although that may not have come across), whereas you seem to be implying that the failure mode is so prevalent that it would be better not to try to be a good overlord at all.
Am I understanding your position correctly?
Partially. Yes, I would assert that the failure mode you’re talking about is prevalent (and point to a LOT of history to support that assertion; no one is evil is his own story). However the main point in the quote we’re talking about isn’t quite that, I think. Instead, consider such concepts as “autonomy”, “individuality”, and “diversity”.