Blaming the Pioneer Plaque for the progressive degredation sounds like it makes sense at first, but the point of the Pioneer Plaque thing is that this Voldemort is supposed to be smarter than canon Voldemort, and a Pioneer Plaque horcrux superior. That theory makes the Pioneer Plaque horcrux inferior. Also I’m pretty sure Voldemort has other horcruxes, including Roger Bacon’s diary and quite possibly ones hidden in the other locations Harry suggested when discussing how to get rid of a Dementor.
Blaming the Pioneer Plaque for the progressive degredation sounds like it makes sense at first, but the point of the Pioneer Plaque thing is that this Voldemort is supposed to be smarter than canon Voldemort, and a Pioneer Plaque horcrux superior. That theory makes the Pioneer Plaque horcrux inferior.
Smart people still overlook things. A lightspeed delay problem in horcrux syncing would not have come up ever before, so it could have been easily overlooked even by a very smart person, especially one that is not scientifically oriented. If he had been more scientifically oriented and been otherwise interested in Muggle space programs, this possibility might have occured to him and he could have tested it with the moon missions, if he had come up with a way to detect anticipated problems.
Does a Dementor count as a material object? If so, the (now-disproven) fact of their indestructibility would have made them seem to be ideal Horcruxes.
Or, since they are “wounds in the world”, are they simply places where space isn’t?
I wouldn’t necessarily assume that. Quirrel seems to like the idea of being out among the peaceful pure stars; a strategy which dooms his earthly vessel is not necessarily such an issue. And while he’s slowly slipping away, he can fulfill a few last regrets—such as finally becoming Battle Magic Professor at Hogwarts.
He may like being out among the stars, but that’s no reason to cut his fun on Earth short unnecessarily. Like, if the Earth were to be destroyed, and all the horcruxes hidden there with it, he’d regard having the Pioneer horcrux left as vastly superior to nonexistence, but that doesn’t mean he wouldn’t like to continue hanging out on Earth.
Edit: Also, if he’s afraid that someone like Harry could accidentally explode the Sun, taking the Pioneer Plaque with it, he has reason to stick around to stop that from happening. Also, if Bacon’s diary wasn’t a horcrux, how do you account for Voldemort telling Harry it’s nearly indestructible?
We don’t know of any such charms, and why would Voldemort settle for a less degree of protection, when he has so few qualms about killing? My guess is he murdered the owner to make the horcrux.
Canon Voldemort chose his horcruxes for symbolic value. HPMOR!Voldemort presumably chose the plaque for its indestructibility by human hands (though it might have symbolic value too). On the other hand, Bacon’s diary has nothing to commend it in terms of material (it is just a book), and Voldemort has no special attachment to Muggle science as a whole—indeed he is inimical to much of it.
There’s a couple potential advantages to having a horcrux in Harry’s possession: Harry’s then guarding it, and it might be used to possess Harry later on. Though that’s less helpful if, as in canon, Harry is a horcrux. But even then, I’d hardly be shocked to see Voldemort creating an additional horcrux on a whim.
On the other hand, Bacon’s diary has nothing to commend it in terms of material (it is just a book),
I’m not arguing, but how do we know that? IIRC we’ve never seen exactly what was in there, and Harry never got around to reading it. And it doesn’t sound like Quirrell to just make a gift just because it’s an “old rare item”, especially since he doesn’t quite like science and Bacon’s relevance to Harry is not that he had magic, but that he was a (proto-)scientist.
We’re told that Bacon’s research into magic did not get very far without a wand, and he never had any formal magical training since he refused his letter. It thus seems unlikely that he enchanted his diary in any interesting way.
Blaming the Pioneer Plaque for the progressive degredation sounds like it makes sense at first, but the point of the Pioneer Plaque thing is that this Voldemort is supposed to be smarter than canon Voldemort, and a Pioneer Plaque horcrux superior. That theory makes the Pioneer Plaque horcrux inferior. Also I’m pretty sure Voldemort has other horcruxes, including Roger Bacon’s diary and quite possibly ones hidden in the other locations Harry suggested when discussing how to get rid of a Dementor.
No data could ever have existed in past for the effect of Horcruxes at interplanetary distances. He may well simply be a victim of unknown unknowns.
Smart people still overlook things. A lightspeed delay problem in horcrux syncing would not have come up ever before, so it could have been easily overlooked even by a very smart person, especially one that is not scientifically oriented. If he had been more scientifically oriented and been otherwise interested in Muggle space programs, this possibility might have occured to him and he could have tested it with the moon missions, if he had come up with a way to detect anticipated problems.
maybe that’s why he hasn’t killed harry after hearing the prophecy.
he needs help in finding his horcrux.
which he won’t, because space is huge.
Does a Dementor count as a material object? If so, the (now-disproven) fact of their indestructibility would have made them seem to be ideal Horcruxes.
Or, since they are “wounds in the world”, are they simply places where space isn’t?
Since they eat souls … probably not an ideal place for a soul-fragment, yeah.
Or would they simply “eat” the Horcrux? A dementor is no fun place to be when you have just, like, died (as in “lost a body”).
I wouldn’t necessarily assume that. Quirrel seems to like the idea of being out among the peaceful pure stars; a strategy which dooms his earthly vessel is not necessarily such an issue. And while he’s slowly slipping away, he can fulfill a few last regrets—such as finally becoming Battle Magic Professor at Hogwarts.
He may like being out among the stars, but that’s no reason to cut his fun on Earth short unnecessarily. Like, if the Earth were to be destroyed, and all the horcruxes hidden there with it, he’d regard having the Pioneer horcrux left as vastly superior to nonexistence, but that doesn’t mean he wouldn’t like to continue hanging out on Earth.
Edit: Also, if he’s afraid that someone like Harry could accidentally explode the Sun, taking the Pioneer Plaque with it, he has reason to stick around to stop that from happening. Also, if Bacon’s diary wasn’t a horcrux, how do you account for Voldemort telling Harry it’s nearly indestructible?
That isn’t necessarily the same level of indestructibility as a horcrux. It could just be a standard charm placed on rare books.
We don’t know of any such charms, and why would Voldemort settle for a less degree of protection, when he has so few qualms about killing? My guess is he murdered the owner to make the horcrux.
Canon Voldemort chose his horcruxes for symbolic value. HPMOR!Voldemort presumably chose the plaque for its indestructibility by human hands (though it might have symbolic value too). On the other hand, Bacon’s diary has nothing to commend it in terms of material (it is just a book), and Voldemort has no special attachment to Muggle science as a whole—indeed he is inimical to much of it.
There’s a couple potential advantages to having a horcrux in Harry’s possession: Harry’s then guarding it, and it might be used to possess Harry later on. Though that’s less helpful if, as in canon, Harry is a horcrux. But even then, I’d hardly be shocked to see Voldemort creating an additional horcrux on a whim.
“You can never have enough big white belts, remember that.”
I’m not arguing, but how do we know that? IIRC we’ve never seen exactly what was in there, and Harry never got around to reading it. And it doesn’t sound like Quirrell to just make a gift just because it’s an “old rare item”, especially since he doesn’t quite like science and Bacon’s relevance to Harry is not that he had magic, but that he was a (proto-)scientist.
We’re told that Bacon’s research into magic did not get very far without a wand, and he never had any formal magical training since he refused his letter. It thus seems unlikely that he enchanted his diary in any interesting way.
We have only Quirrell’s word for most of that, though it seems plausible to me too.
He gave it to Harry. It’s something Harry would unquestionably want.
Unfortunately, it hasn’t come up again, so maybe not.