If they are agentic, they will have killeveryone as an instrumental goal, because humanity will likely be obstacle for whatever future plans it will have.
I think this is broadly incorrect, because boundary-respecting norms seem quite natural, and not exterminating a civilization is trivially cheap on cosmic scale. There doesn’t need to be much in common between values to respect such norms, I’m calling such values “loosely aligned”, and they don’t need to be similar to not have killeveryone as an instrumental goal.
Killeveryone is still an instrumental goal for paperclip maximizers, which might have an advantage in self-improving in an aligned-with-themselves manner, because with simple explicit goals it might be much easier to ensure that stronger successor AGIs with different architectures are still pursuing the same goals. On the other hand, loosely-aligned-with-humanity AGIs that have complicated values might want to hold off on self-improvement to ensure alignment, and remain non-superintelligent for a long time. As a result, simple-valued AGIs might be particularly dangerous to them, because they are liable to FOOM immediately.
I think this is broadly incorrect, because boundary-respecting norms seem quite natural, and not exterminating a civilization is trivially cheap on cosmic scale. There doesn’t need to be much in common between values to respect such norms, I’m calling such values “loosely aligned”, and they don’t need to be similar to not have killeveryone as an instrumental goal.
Killeveryone is still an instrumental goal for paperclip maximizers, which might have an advantage in self-improving in an aligned-with-themselves manner, because with simple explicit goals it might be much easier to ensure that stronger successor AGIs with different architectures are still pursuing the same goals. On the other hand, loosely-aligned-with-humanity AGIs that have complicated values might want to hold off on self-improvement to ensure alignment, and remain non-superintelligent for a long time. As a result, simple-valued AGIs might be particularly dangerous to them, because they are liable to FOOM immediately.