If you’re considering opening a baby farm, not opening the baby farm doesn’t mean the babies get to live fulfilling lives: it means they don’t get to exist, so that point is moot.
If you view human potential as valuable then you end up saying something like that people should maximise that via breeding up to whatever the resource boundary is for meaningful human life. Unless that is implicitly bound—which I think to be a reasonable assumption to make for most people’s likely world views.
If you’re considering opening a baby farm, not opening the baby farm doesn’t mean the babies get to live fulfilling lives: it means they don’t get to exist, so that point is moot.
If you view human potential as valuable then you end up saying something like that people should maximise that via breeding up to whatever the resource boundary is for meaningful human life. Unless that is implicitly bound—which I think to be a reasonable assumption to make for most people’s likely world views.