Upvoted. Thanks for the clarifications. It seems you’re not talking about the mere presence of theists in the rationality community at all, but rather in spite of his theism, being at least poorly articulated, and everything else specious in his views, I agree it’s indeed alarming JBP might be seen as an exemplar of rationality. It’s my impression it is still a minority of community members who agree JBP is impressive. I’ve currently no more thoughts on how significant that minority is, or what its portents for the rest of rationality might be.
Upvoted. Thanks for the clarifications. It seems you’re not talking about the mere presence of theists in the rationality community at all, but rather in spite of his theism, being at least poorly articulated, and everything else specious in his views, I agree it’s indeed alarming JBP might be seen as an exemplar of rationality. It’s my impression it is still a minority of community members who agree JBP is impressive. I’ve currently no more thoughts on how significant that minority is, or what its portents for the rest of rationality might be.