I’m not claiming that there is a mysterious fact about physics here, or that what I’m saying contradicts what you’re saying. I sketched a point that makes sense to me and stands on its own, vaguely hoping but not claiming that it’s relevant or helpful. It can be very difficult to communicate or discuss an issue that’s not clearly formulated, so that exchanging smaller and more clearly formulated arguments that don’t depend on comprehending the specific issue is more practical.
Well if you’re not saying it, then I’m saying it: this is a mysterious fact about physics ;P
I interpreted “which is not the same as being some sort of refutation” as being disagreement, and I knew my use of the word “contradicts” was not entirely correct according to its definition, but I couldn’t think of a more accurate word so I figured it was “close enough” and used it anyway (which is a bad communication habit I should probably try to overcome, now that I’m explicitly noticing it). I’m sorry if I came across harshly in my comment.
I’m not claiming that there is a mysterious fact about physics here, or that what I’m saying contradicts what you’re saying. I sketched a point that makes sense to me and stands on its own, vaguely hoping but not claiming that it’s relevant or helpful. It can be very difficult to communicate or discuss an issue that’s not clearly formulated, so that exchanging smaller and more clearly formulated arguments that don’t depend on comprehending the specific issue is more practical.
Well if you’re not saying it, then I’m saying it: this is a mysterious fact about physics ;P
I interpreted “which is not the same as being some sort of refutation” as being disagreement, and I knew my use of the word “contradicts” was not entirely correct according to its definition, but I couldn’t think of a more accurate word so I figured it was “close enough” and used it anyway (which is a bad communication habit I should probably try to overcome, now that I’m explicitly noticing it). I’m sorry if I came across harshly in my comment.