I definitely share your concern that evidence which isn’t “scientific” matters, but I still think whether or not there is scientific evidence isn’t entirely irrelevant to decision-making when we care about creating organizations that consistently make good decisions.
Currently, we definitely care far too much about scientific evidence, but I disagree that the concept is entirely bullshit.
I am not saying it is bullshit. But failing to consider information also has a cost. And for some fields, “consistently good decisions” may not even be possible.
I definitely share your concern that evidence which isn’t “scientific” matters, but I still think whether or not there is scientific evidence isn’t entirely irrelevant to decision-making when we care about creating organizations that consistently make good decisions.
Currently, we definitely care far too much about scientific evidence, but I disagree that the concept is entirely bullshit.
I am not saying it is bullshit. But failing to consider information also has a cost. And for some fields, “consistently good decisions” may not even be possible.