As someone who does both data analysis and algebraic topology, my take is that TDA showed promise but ultimately there’s something missing such that it’s not at full capacity. Either the formalism isn’t developed enough or it’s being consistently used on the wrong kinds of datasets. Which is kind of a shame, because it’s the kind of thing that should work beautifully and in some cases even does!
As someone who does both data analysis and algebraic topology, my take is that TDA showed promise but ultimately there’s something missing such that it’s not at full capacity. Either the formalism isn’t developed enough or it’s being consistently used on the wrong kinds of datasets. Which is kind of a shame, because it’s the kind of thing that should work beautifully and in some cases even does!