The utilitarian philosopher RM Hare has proposed a solution along the lines you suggest, it’s called two-level utilitarianism. From Wikipedia:
As a descriptive model of the two levels, Hare posited two extreme cases of people, one of whom would only use critical moral thinking and the other of whom would only use intuitive moral thinking. The former he called the ‘archangel’ and the latter the ‘prole’.
I think the concept has merit, but if you’re smart and willing enough to do it, you’d have to act according to the “critical level” (conventional consequentialism) anyway.
The utilitarian philosopher RM Hare has proposed a solution along the lines you suggest, it’s called two-level utilitarianism. From Wikipedia:
I think the concept has merit, but if you’re smart and willing enough to do it, you’d have to act according to the “critical level” (conventional consequentialism) anyway.