These 4 beefs are different and less serious than the original accusations, or at least feel that way to me. Retconning a motte after the bailey is lost? That said, they’re reasonable beefs for someone to have.
These 4 beefs aren’t about the original accusations; Ozy’s previous post was about the original accusations. Rather, these 4 beefs are concerns that Ozy already had about Effective Altruism in general, and which the drama around Nonlinear ended up highlighting as a side-effect.
Because these beefs are more general, they’re not as specifically going to capture the ways Alice and Chloe were harmed. However I think on a community level, these 4 dynamics should arguably be a bigger concern than the more specific abuse Alice and Chloe faced, because they seem to some extent self-reinforcing, e.g. “Do It For The Gram” will attract and reward a certain kind of people who aren’t going to be effectively altruistic.
These 4 beefs are different and less serious than the original accusations, or at least feel that way to me. Retconning a motte after the bailey is lost? That said, they’re reasonable beefs for someone to have.
These 4 beefs aren’t about the original accusations; Ozy’s previous post was about the original accusations. Rather, these 4 beefs are concerns that Ozy already had about Effective Altruism in general, and which the drama around Nonlinear ended up highlighting as a side-effect.
Because these beefs are more general, they’re not as specifically going to capture the ways Alice and Chloe were harmed. However I think on a community level, these 4 dynamics should arguably be a bigger concern than the more specific abuse Alice and Chloe faced, because they seem to some extent self-reinforcing, e.g. “Do It For The Gram” will attract and reward a certain kind of people who aren’t going to be effectively altruistic.
I guess I should also say, see this post for LW discussion of Ozy’s review of the original accusations: https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/wNqufsqkicMNxabZz/practically-a-book-review-appendix-to-nonlinear-s-evidence