Pointing out that your argument appears to be a form of special pleading—you introduced a general rule (“wearing puffy shirts is bad”), I pointed out counterexamples (Depp, also women), you picked one of these and said “but he is special”.
I see. Through counterexamples we can demonstrate anything to be acceptable fashion in certain scenarios.
The puffy shirt is irrelevant (I feel like arguing but let me try and resist that). I found your counterexamples about t-shirts to be stronger evidence, and I did adjust my beliefs. I can offer you no good evidence on how people on average perceive t-shirts with slogans on them.
Pointing out that your argument appears to be a form of special pleading—you introduced a general rule (“wearing puffy shirts is bad”), I pointed out counterexamples (Depp, also women), you picked one of these and said “but he is special”.
I see. Through counterexamples we can demonstrate anything to be acceptable fashion in certain scenarios.
The puffy shirt is irrelevant (I feel like arguing but let me try and resist that). I found your counterexamples about t-shirts to be stronger evidence, and I did adjust my beliefs. I can offer you no good evidence on how people on average perceive t-shirts with slogans on them.