Therefore I take the fact that we exist as evidence that arbitrary amounts of time travel aren’t possible in our universe...
Doesn’t follow. The fact that you exist in a certain way isn’t evidence about prior probability of your existing in this way. (Your points (1) and (2) are arguments about prior probability that don’t have this problem; using observations that depend on the value of prior probability also works.)
Doesn’t follow. The fact that you exist in a certain way isn’t evidence about prior probability of your existing in this way. (Your points (1) and (2) are arguments about prior probability that don’t have this problem; using observations that depend on the value of prior probability also works.)
Hm. It looks like my intuition has a bug. I’ll have to think about it more.