But if I did not already agree, your comment would not have convinced me.
Right. It wasn’t an argument, it was a concept intended to give clearer structure to your own impression. Epistemic rationality, for example, is targeted at giving you accurate estimates, whatever they are, even though it’s not domain-specific and it doesn’t argue for specific positions on specific questions.
But if I did not already agree, your comment would not have convinced me.
Essentially, I think it would be appropriate if it were actually supported, not just supportable.
Right. It wasn’t an argument, it was a concept intended to give clearer structure to your own impression. Epistemic rationality, for example, is targeted at giving you accurate estimates, whatever they are, even though it’s not domain-specific and it doesn’t argue for specific positions on specific questions.