Nick_Tarleton comments on Decision theory: Why Pearl helps reduce “could” and “would”, but still leaves us with at least three alternatives

[Nick_Tarleton]

But it’d be pretty damn hard in real life to put me into a literally one-shot, uncoordinated, no-communication, true PD where I’m running TDT, the other person is running honor with no inkling that I’m TDT, and the utilities at stake outweigh that which constrains me not to betray honorable people.

Mostly because of the “one-shot, uncoordinated, no-communication, true… utilities at stake outweigh” parts, I would think. The really relevant question conditions on those things.