I am not suggesting either of those things. You enumerated a bunch of ways we might use cutting-edge technologies to facilitate intelligence amplification, and I am simply noting that frontier AI seems like it will inevitably become one such technology in the near future.
On a psychologizing note, your comment seems like part of a pattern of trying to wriggle out of doing things the way that is hard that will work.
Completely unsure what you are referring to or the other datapoints in this supposed pattern. Strikes me as somewhat ad-hominem-y unless I am misunderstanding what you are saying.
AI helping to do good science wouldn’t make the work any less hard—it just would cause the same hard work to happen faster.
hard+works is better than easy+not-works
seems trivially true. I think the full picture is something like:
Of course agree that if AI-assisted science is not effective, it would be worse to do than something that is slower but effective. Seems like whether or not this sort of system could be effective is an empirical question that will be largely settled in the next few years.
I am not suggesting either of those things. You enumerated a bunch of ways we might use cutting-edge technologies to facilitate intelligence amplification, and I am simply noting that frontier AI seems like it will inevitably become one such technology in the near future.
Completely unsure what you are referring to or the other datapoints in this supposed pattern. Strikes me as somewhat ad-hominem-y unless I am misunderstanding what you are saying.
AI helping to do good science wouldn’t make the work any less hard—it just would cause the same hard work to happen faster.
seems trivially true. I think the full picture is something like:
efficient+effective > inefficient+effective > efficient+ineffective > inefficient+ineffective
Of course agree that if AI-assisted science is not effective, it would be worse to do than something that is slower but effective. Seems like whether or not this sort of system could be effective is an empirical question that will be largely settled in the next few years.