At least obviously wrong by my value system where believing true things is a core value.
Beware identity. It seems that a hero shouldn’t kill, ever, but sometimes it’s the right thing to do. Unless it’s your sole value, there will be situations where it should give way.
Unless it’s your sole value, there will be situations where it should give way.
This seems like it should generally be true but in practice I haven’t encountered any plausible examples where I prefer ignorance. This includes a number of hypotheticals where many people claim they would prefer ignorance which leads me to believe the value I place on truth is outside the norm.
Truth / knowledge is a little paradoxical in this sense as well. I believe that killing is generally wrong but there is no paradox in killing in certain situations because it appears to be the right choice. The feedback effect of truth on your decision making / value defining apparatus makes it unlike other core values that might sometimes be abandoned.
This seems like it should generally be true but in practice I haven’t encountered any plausible examples where I prefer ignorance. This includes a number of hypotheticals where many people claim they would prefer ignorance which leads me to believe the value I place on truth is outside the norm.
I agree with this, my objection is to the particular argument you used, not necessarily the implied conclusion.
Beware identity. It seems that a hero shouldn’t kill, ever, but sometimes it’s the right thing to do. Unless it’s your sole value, there will be situations where it should give way.
This seems like it should generally be true but in practice I haven’t encountered any plausible examples where I prefer ignorance. This includes a number of hypotheticals where many people claim they would prefer ignorance which leads me to believe the value I place on truth is outside the norm.
Truth / knowledge is a little paradoxical in this sense as well. I believe that killing is generally wrong but there is no paradox in killing in certain situations because it appears to be the right choice. The feedback effect of truth on your decision making / value defining apparatus makes it unlike other core values that might sometimes be abandoned.
I agree with this, my objection is to the particular argument you used, not necessarily the implied conclusion.