It’s important to distinguish changes in values, from updating of knowledge about values in response to moral arguments. The latter emphatically shouldn’t be opposed, otherwise you turn morally stupid.
That sounds like it would be isomorphic to always encouraging the updating of instrumental values, but not terminal ones, which strikes me as an unquestionably good idea in all cases where stupidity is not a terminal value.
You don’t update values, you update knowledge about values. Knowledge about terminal values might be as incomplete as knowledge about instrumental values. The difference is that with instrumental values, you usually update indifference, while with “terminal” values you start out with some idea of preference.
What about newborns? If they have same terminal values as adults, then Kolmogorov complexity of terminal values should not exceed one of genome. Thus a) terminal values are updated or b) terminal values are not very complex or c) knowledge about terminal values is part of terminal values, which imply a).
It’s important to distinguish changes in values, from updating of knowledge about values in response to moral arguments. The latter emphatically shouldn’t be opposed, otherwise you turn morally stupid.
That sounds like it would be isomorphic to always encouraging the updating of instrumental values, but not terminal ones, which strikes me as an unquestionably good idea in all cases where stupidity is not a terminal value.
You don’t update values, you update knowledge about values. Knowledge about terminal values might be as incomplete as knowledge about instrumental values. The difference is that with instrumental values, you usually update indifference, while with “terminal” values you start out with some idea of preference.
What about newborns? If they have same terminal values as adults, then Kolmogorov complexity of terminal values should not exceed one of genome. Thus a) terminal values are updated or b) terminal values are not very complex or c) knowledge about terminal values is part of terminal values, which imply a).