“Random” is the null value we can give as an answer to the question “What is our prior?”
I think the word you are looking for here is “equiprobable”.
It’s propper to have equiprobable prior between outcomes of a probability experiment, if you do not have any reason to expect that one is more likely than the other.
It’s ridiculous to have equiprobable prior between states that are not even possible outcomes of the experiment, to the best of your knowledge.
You are not an incorporeal ghost that could’ve inhabited any body throughout human history. You are your parents child. You couldn’t have been born before them or after they are already dead. Thinking otherwise is as silly as throwing a 6 sided die and then expecting to receive any outcome from a 20 sided die.
I was anthropically sampled out of some space
You were not anthropically sampled. You were born as a result of a physical process in a real world that you are trying to approximate as a probability experiment. This process had nothing to do with selecting universes that support conscious processes. This process has already been instantiated in a specific universe and has very limited time frame for your existence.
You will have to ignore all this knowledge and pretend that the process is completely different, without any evidence to back it up, to satisfy the conditions of Doomsday argument.
I think the word you are looking for here is “equiprobable”.
It’s propper to have equiprobable prior between outcomes of a probability experiment, if you do not have any reason to expect that one is more likely than the other.
It’s ridiculous to have equiprobable prior between states that are not even possible outcomes of the experiment, to the best of your knowledge.
You are not an incorporeal ghost that could’ve inhabited any body throughout human history. You are your parents child. You couldn’t have been born before them or after they are already dead. Thinking otherwise is as silly as throwing a 6 sided die and then expecting to receive any outcome from a 20 sided die.
You were not anthropically sampled. You were born as a result of a physical process in a real world that you are trying to approximate as a probability experiment. This process had nothing to do with selecting universes that support conscious processes. This process has already been instantiated in a specific universe and has very limited time frame for your existence.
You will have to ignore all this knowledge and pretend that the process is completely different, without any evidence to back it up, to satisfy the conditions of Doomsday argument.