Could you give some examples of the Curse of Doom? You’ve described it at a high level, but I cannot think of any examples after thinking about it for a while.
I’m highly experienced at the combination of probability theory, algorithms, and big business data processing. Big businesses have a data problem, they ask a consultant from my company, the consultant realizes there’s a probabilistic algorithm component to the problem, and they call me. I guess if I didn’t exist, that would be a Curse of Doom, but that seems pretty farfetched to call it a Curse. If I wasn’t around, a few big companies would have slightly less efficient algorithms. It’s millions of dollars over the years, but not a big deal in the scheme of things.
Also, ”Curse of Doom” is an extremely generic term. You might find it sticks to people‘s brains better if you gave it a more specific name. “Curse of the missing polymath”?
Three categories; there’s things that aren’t at all cursed because they only take one skillset or because their overlapping skillset is common, things that are a bit cursed where we have cases where the overlapping skillsets happened to work out but we have reason to expect there should be more, and things that are very cursed indeed. Note that, especially when looking at the difference between “Not at all cursed” and “a bit cursed” you’re
Not at all cursed: Musicals or plays about the experience of being a writer or playwright. (Tick Tick Boom, Bells are Ringing, Birds of Paradise, Cabaret, City of Angels, Merrily We Roll Along...) Software that fixes problems encountered by software engineers. (Git, Leetcode, JIRA, Stack Exchange, and that’s not counting this list of IDEs.) Legal or bureaucrat collective organizations that have done their paperwork. (See this list of bar associations just for Massachusetts.)
A bit cursed: Musicals or plays about the experience of being a U.S. president. (Bloody Bloody Andrew Jackson, Hamilton, arguably 1776.) Computer programs about doing your taxes. (H&R, TurboTax.) Rationalist or EA organizations that have done their paperwork (see this post and ctrl+f for “king umbrella”) or to pick another example with a larger population, software engineering associations that have done their paperwork.
Very cursed: Musicals or plays about being illiterate. Computer programs about Amish farming techniques. Anarchist organizations that have done their paperwork.
Note that a Very Cursed section I write might have some hits, mainly when it winds up being worth paying someone. It’s hard to write a list of the things nobody thought to make, since obviously nobody thought to make them. Someone who had no knowledge of how the internet worked would have a hard time realizing that Google Docs or Amazon’s online shopping would be options someone might try. It might be a better intuition pump to look at the gradient between Not At All Cursed and A Bit Cursed; what’s the difference between lawyers and software engineers that makes it so lawyers have a dozen bar associations in MA, with their own bylaws and articles? The hypothesis I’m putting forward is that being a lawyer selects hard for being comfortable with paperwork, while being a software engineer doesn’t select for that at all.
Or to reuse one of the examples I had in the main article: A book about an unappreciated writer or English teacher is a cliche. A book about an unappreciated janitor or waste collector is not a cliche. My hypothesis is this is because being a writer selects for writing ability, while being a janitor doesn’t.
(See this list of bar associations just for Massachusetts.)
Minor point but this is often misunderstood. These bar associations are essentially networking groups for lawyers. They are not required in order to practice. What’s required to practice is bar admission which is different. There’s also a federal bar admission, but that’s only two, not dozens.
Could you give some examples of the Curse of Doom? You’ve described it at a high level, but I cannot think of any examples after thinking about it for a while.
I’m highly experienced at the combination of probability theory, algorithms, and big business data processing. Big businesses have a data problem, they ask a consultant from my company, the consultant realizes there’s a probabilistic algorithm component to the problem, and they call me. I guess if I didn’t exist, that would be a Curse of Doom, but that seems pretty farfetched to call it a Curse. If I wasn’t around, a few big companies would have slightly less efficient algorithms. It’s millions of dollars over the years, but not a big deal in the scheme of things.
Also, ”Curse of Doom” is an extremely generic term. You might find it sticks to people‘s brains better if you gave it a more specific name. “Curse of the missing polymath”?
Three categories; there’s things that aren’t at all cursed because they only take one skillset or because their overlapping skillset is common, things that are a bit cursed where we have cases where the overlapping skillsets happened to work out but we have reason to expect there should be more, and things that are very cursed indeed. Note that, especially when looking at the difference between “Not at all cursed” and “a bit cursed” you’re
Not at all cursed: Musicals or plays about the experience of being a writer or playwright. (Tick Tick Boom, Bells are Ringing, Birds of Paradise, Cabaret, City of Angels, Merrily We Roll Along...) Software that fixes problems encountered by software engineers. (Git, Leetcode, JIRA, Stack Exchange, and that’s not counting this list of IDEs.) Legal or bureaucrat collective organizations that have done their paperwork. (See this list of bar associations just for Massachusetts.)
A bit cursed: Musicals or plays about the experience of being a U.S. president. (Bloody Bloody Andrew Jackson, Hamilton, arguably 1776.) Computer programs about doing your taxes. (H&R, TurboTax.) Rationalist or EA organizations that have done their paperwork (see this post and ctrl+f for “king umbrella”) or to pick another example with a larger population, software engineering associations that have done their paperwork.
Very cursed: Musicals or plays about being illiterate. Computer programs about Amish farming techniques. Anarchist organizations that have done their paperwork.
Note that a Very Cursed section I write might have some hits, mainly when it winds up being worth paying someone. It’s hard to write a list of the things nobody thought to make, since obviously nobody thought to make them. Someone who had no knowledge of how the internet worked would have a hard time realizing that Google Docs or Amazon’s online shopping would be options someone might try. It might be a better intuition pump to look at the gradient between Not At All Cursed and A Bit Cursed; what’s the difference between lawyers and software engineers that makes it so lawyers have a dozen bar associations in MA, with their own bylaws and articles? The hypothesis I’m putting forward is that being a lawyer selects hard for being comfortable with paperwork, while being a software engineer doesn’t select for that at all.
Or to reuse one of the examples I had in the main article: A book about an unappreciated writer or English teacher is a cliche. A book about an unappreciated janitor or waste collector is not a cliche. My hypothesis is this is because being a writer selects for writing ability, while being a janitor doesn’t.
Minor point but this is often misunderstood. These bar associations are essentially networking groups for lawyers. They are not required in order to practice. What’s required to practice is bar admission which is different. There’s also a federal bar admission, but that’s only two, not dozens.