Do you think there would be interest in an “Irrationality Quotes” Thread?
To be honest, these threads are full of such great information that I can’t help imagining putting something absolutely useless or ridiculous in it. I just can’t resist how it would look to be scrolling through such properly-formatted and thoughtful knowledge from reputable people and then come across, just as perfectly-formatted, presented totally seriously...something like “Some dogs can’t resist a tasty morsel of feces.” -Theresa A. Fuess. (http://vetmed.illinois.edu/petcolumns/petcols_article_page.php?PETCOLID=77&URL=0) …just tucked in perfectly normally with everything else.
Or, more appropriately for its own thread, quotes that demonstrate the exact opposite of what LessWrong represents, as a means of reminding people of the various forms that irrationality takes when presented by serious opposition.
That’s funny, I searched for “Irrationality Quotes” and that led me to believe it hadn’t.
EDIT: Actually now that I think about this...Alicorn may of course not even be suggesting that it’s a bad idea due to a previous thread in 2011, but just in general, if the last time the topic came up was 3 years ago, it’s probably fine or even preferable to bring it up again in some form if people found it interesting before. I’m sure there have been a few new members in the last 3 years, and a few more irrational things have been said. In general, people discuss various relevant topics more than once, and a time horizon for repeating them would probably reasonably be on the scale of months at the most. Otherwise, it’s guaranteeing the slow death of the site.
I have no particular opinion on whether you ought to start your thread. The links were just FYI because I thought I remembered what might generously be termed prior art on the subject.
Do you think there would be interest in an “Irrationality Quotes” Thread?
To be honest, these threads are full of such great information that I can’t help imagining putting something absolutely useless or ridiculous in it. I just can’t resist how it would look to be scrolling through such properly-formatted and thoughtful knowledge from reputable people and then come across, just as perfectly-formatted, presented totally seriously...something like “Some dogs can’t resist a tasty morsel of feces.” -Theresa A. Fuess. (http://vetmed.illinois.edu/petcolumns/petcols_article_page.php?PETCOLID=77&URL=0) …just tucked in perfectly normally with everything else.
Or, more appropriately for its own thread, quotes that demonstrate the exact opposite of what LessWrong represents, as a means of reminding people of the various forms that irrationality takes when presented by serious opposition.
I’ll give it a go.
Similar ideas have been posted before.
That’s funny, I searched for “Irrationality Quotes” and that led me to believe it hadn’t.
EDIT: Actually now that I think about this...Alicorn may of course not even be suggesting that it’s a bad idea due to a previous thread in 2011, but just in general, if the last time the topic came up was 3 years ago, it’s probably fine or even preferable to bring it up again in some form if people found it interesting before. I’m sure there have been a few new members in the last 3 years, and a few more irrational things have been said. In general, people discuss various relevant topics more than once, and a time horizon for repeating them would probably reasonably be on the scale of months at the most. Otherwise, it’s guaranteeing the slow death of the site.
I have no particular opinion on whether you ought to start your thread. The links were just FYI because I thought I remembered what might generously be termed prior art on the subject.
Whenever I feel like reading nonsense, I browse the Conservapedia news section.