/shrugs. I know I’m biased and all but I didn’t think it was that terrible. I spent like two hours editing it before posting. People sure are being mean about it though, so idk. I guess maybe I’ll give up on trying to improve my fiction writing skill for now… Maybe it’s a ‘you have it or you don’t’ thing.
If it makes you feel any better, Eliezer’s April 1st fiction post wasn’t accepted well, and was deleted in the end as well.
At any rate, you had some clever things in there, but it was mostly too vague and random to convey your point much further than telling us that you have some sort of a criticism.
Maybe it’s a ‘you have it or you don’t’ thing.
I do not believe this to be the case, based on having seen some people’s improvements over time, but I have not researched this.
Well, there are definitely a lot of people who’re bad enough that I’d write off the idea of trying to give them advice as hopeless. But I’d suggest that posting bits of fiction directly to Less Wrong’s discussion board isn’t a very good place to look for that sort of advice in the first place.
/shrugs. I know I’m biased and all but I didn’t think it was that terrible. I spent like two hours editing it before posting. People sure are being mean about it though, so idk. I guess maybe I’ll give up on trying to improve my fiction writing skill for now… Maybe it’s a ‘you have it or you don’t’ thing.
If it makes you feel any better, Eliezer’s April 1st fiction post wasn’t accepted well, and was deleted in the end as well.
At any rate, you had some clever things in there, but it was mostly too vague and random to convey your point much further than telling us that you have some sort of a criticism.
I do not believe this to be the case, based on having seen some people’s improvements over time, but I have not researched this.
Well, there are definitely a lot of people who’re bad enough that I’d write off the idea of trying to give them advice as hopeless. But I’d suggest that posting bits of fiction directly to Less Wrong’s discussion board isn’t a very good place to look for that sort of advice in the first place.