It looks to me as if the two of you are talking past each other. I think knb means “it doesn’t seem to me like things that would have to be complex hallucination if there were no gods are that common”, and is kinda assuming there are in fact no gods; whereas Will means “actual complex hallucinations aren’t common” and is kinda assuming that apparent manifestations of gods (or something of the sort) are common.
I second knb’s request that Will give some description of his own encounters with god(s), but I expect him to be unwilling to do so with much detail. [EDITED to add: And in fact I see he’s explicitly declined to do so elsewhere in the thread.]
I think hallucination is more common than many people think it is (Oliver Sacks recently wrote a book that I think makes this claim, but I haven’t read it), and I am not aware of good evidence that apparent manifestations of gods dramatic enough to be called “outright complex hallucination” are common enough to require a huge fraction of people to be anosognosic if gods aren’t real—Will, if you’re reading this, would you care to say more?
Upon further reflection it is very difficult for me to guess what percentage of people experience what evidence and of what nature and intensity. I do not feel comfortable generalizing from the experiences of people in my life, for obvious reasons and some less obvious ones. I believe this doesn’t ultimately matter so much for me, personally, because what I’ve seen implies it is common enough and clear enough to require a perhaps-heavy explanation. But for others trying to guess at more general base rates, I think I don’t have much insight to offer.
It looks to me as if the two of you are talking past each other. I think knb means “it doesn’t seem to me like things that would have to be complex hallucination if there were no gods are that common”, and is kinda assuming there are in fact no gods; whereas Will means “actual complex hallucinations aren’t common” and is kinda assuming that apparent manifestations of gods (or something of the sort) are common.
I second knb’s request that Will give some description of his own encounters with god(s), but I expect him to be unwilling to do so with much detail. [EDITED to add: And in fact I see he’s explicitly declined to do so elsewhere in the thread.]
I think hallucination is more common than many people think it is (Oliver Sacks recently wrote a book that I think makes this claim, but I haven’t read it), and I am not aware of good evidence that apparent manifestations of gods dramatic enough to be called “outright complex hallucination” are common enough to require a huge fraction of people to be anosognosic if gods aren’t real—Will, if you’re reading this, would you care to say more?
Upon further reflection it is very difficult for me to guess what percentage of people experience what evidence and of what nature and intensity. I do not feel comfortable generalizing from the experiences of people in my life, for obvious reasons and some less obvious ones. I believe this doesn’t ultimately matter so much for me, personally, because what I’ve seen implies it is common enough and clear enough to require a perhaps-heavy explanation. But for others trying to guess at more general base rates, I think I don’t have much insight to offer.