I think we can use the same method Eliezer applied to the regular epiphenomenalist Zombie argument to deal with this, weaker one.
Whether your mind interprets certain colour in a certain way actually has causal effects on the world. Namely, things that appear beautiful to you in our world may not appear beautiful to your qualia inversed counterpart. Which naturally affects your behaviour: whether you look at a certain object more, whether you buy a certain object and so on.
This is even more obvious for people with selective colour blindness. Suppose your mind is unable to distinguish between qualia of blueness and redness. And suppose there are three objects: A is red, B is blue and C is green. In our world you can’t distinguish between objects A and B. But in the qualia inversed world you wouldn’t be able to distinguish between objects B and C.
And if you try to switch to substance dualist version—all the reasoning from this post still stands.
I think we can use the same method Eliezer applied to the regular epiphenomenalist Zombie argument to deal with this, weaker one.
Whether your mind interprets certain colour in a certain way actually has causal effects on the world. Namely, things that appear beautiful to you in our world may not appear beautiful to your qualia inversed counterpart. Which naturally affects your behaviour: whether you look at a certain object more, whether you buy a certain object and so on.
This is even more obvious for people with selective colour blindness. Suppose your mind is unable to distinguish between qualia of blueness and redness. And suppose there are three objects: A is red, B is blue and C is green. In our world you can’t distinguish between objects A and B. But in the qualia inversed world you wouldn’t be able to distinguish between objects B and C.
And if you try to switch to substance dualist version—all the reasoning from this post still stands.