So, I think it’s important that LessWrong admins do not get to unilaterally decide that You Are Now Playing a Game With Your Reputation.
Dude, we’re all always playing games with our reputations. That’s, like, what reputation is.
And good for Habyka for saying he feels disappointment at the lack of thoughtfulness and reflection, it’s very much not just permitted but almost mandated by the founder of this place —
Here’s the relevant citation from Well-Kept Gardens:
I confess, for a while I didn’t even understand why communities had such trouble defending themselves—I thought it was pure naivete. It didn’t occur to me that it was an egalitarian instinct to prevent chieftains from getting too much power.
This too:
I have seen rationalist communities die because they trusted their moderators too little.
Let’s give Habryka a little more respect, eh? Disappointment is a perfectly valid thing to be experiencing and he’s certainly conveying it quite mildly and graciously. Admins here did a hell of a job resurrecting this place back from the dead, to express very mild disapproval at a lack of thoughtfulness during a community event is....… well that seems very much on-mission, at least according to Yudkowsky.
I feel confused about how you interpreted my comment, and edited it lightly. For the record, Habryka’s comment seems basically right to me; just wanted to add some nuance.
Dude, we’re all always playing games with our reputations. That’s, like, what reputation is.
And good for Habyka for saying he feels disappointment at the lack of thoughtfulness and reflection, it’s very much not just permitted but almost mandated by the founder of this place —
https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/tscc3e5eujrsEeFN4/well-kept-gardens-die-by-pacifism
https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/RcZCwxFiZzE6X7nsv/what-do-we-mean-by-rationality-1
Here’s the relevant citation from Well-Kept Gardens:
This too:
Let’s give Habryka a little more respect, eh? Disappointment is a perfectly valid thing to be experiencing and he’s certainly conveying it quite mildly and graciously. Admins here did a hell of a job resurrecting this place back from the dead, to express very mild disapproval at a lack of thoughtfulness during a community event is....… well that seems very much on-mission, at least according to Yudkowsky.
I feel confused about how you interpreted my comment, and edited it lightly. For the record, Habryka’s comment seems basically right to me; just wanted to add some nuance.
Ah, I see, I read the original version partially wrong, my mistake. We’re in agreement. Regards.