Another 15 years didn’t make the idea any newer. Being critical of invalid perception or presentation of an idea is more specific and different from “being critical” of the idea. Pointing out that the idea doesn’t clarify specific confusions about why some processes work is different from the idea not referring to machines that make those processes work.
Similarly, forecasting that it won’t work in some timeframe is more specific, and there does seem to have been a change of mind on that (as facts on the ground demand), but the linked post doesn’t seem particularly relevant, there don’t appear to be claims to that effect there, other than on the level of vibes.
Another 15 years didn’t make the idea any newer. Being critical of invalid perception or presentation of an idea is more specific and different from “being critical” of the idea. Pointing out that the idea doesn’t clarify specific confusions about why some processes work is different from the idea not referring to machines that make those processes work.
Similarly, forecasting that it won’t work in some timeframe is more specific, and there does seem to have been a change of mind on that (as facts on the ground demand), but the linked post doesn’t seem particularly relevant, there don’t appear to be claims to that effect there, other than on the level of vibes.