I have no interest in “targeting” religion for annihilation, or anything like that. I don’t disagree with anything you say here. Religion is just one subset of a class of failure mode that theoretically goes underwater when a society becomes saner. For the sake of defining my terms, I guess I’m just using “being religious” as a catchall for “possessing ontological beliefs that are not grounded in empirically knowable facts”, but I’m not really interested in defending the details of that definition. I think people know what cluster in thingspace I’m pointing to when I say “religion”.
Maybe I should have said something like this in the main post, but, consider a society that looks like ours except all school-aged children spend at least a semester studying the Human’s Guide to Words section of the Sequences. How many absolutely stupid thoughts, beliefs, conversations would just never happen in that world? A lot of those thoughts/beliefs/conversations would be religio-centric, and a lot wouldn’t be. The more “rationality interventions” you add, the fewer ostentatiously dumb things are permitted in the wider social milieu, and bad ideas “go underwater”. That’s the idea, anyway.
I have no interest in “targeting” religion for annihilation, or anything like that. I don’t disagree with anything you say here. Religion is just one subset of a class of failure mode that theoretically goes underwater when a society becomes saner. For the sake of defining my terms, I guess I’m just using “being religious” as a catchall for “possessing ontological beliefs that are not grounded in empirically knowable facts”, but I’m not really interested in defending the details of that definition. I think people know what cluster in thingspace I’m pointing to when I say “religion”.
Maybe I should have said something like this in the main post, but, consider a society that looks like ours except all school-aged children spend at least a semester studying the Human’s Guide to Words section of the Sequences. How many absolutely stupid thoughts, beliefs, conversations would just never happen in that world? A lot of those thoughts/beliefs/conversations would be religio-centric, and a lot wouldn’t be. The more “rationality interventions” you add, the fewer ostentatiously dumb things are permitted in the wider social milieu, and bad ideas “go underwater”. That’s the idea, anyway.