So, here is a data point. Maybe not a helpful one.
I’m roughly 1400 on Chess.com. The complexity of the situations was far too high for me (in the time I had spare for this). However I was cautious about AI B and AI D suggesting drastic changes without detailing all options for the other player. For example, AI B suggests taking the queen, then assumes that White will take with the pawn (not the knight). Similarly AI D doesn’t consider the queen taking the h-pawn. This set my intuition on edge, so I lent towards AI A and C.
I’ve also >! used Stockfish on this after selecting my choices. So I’m rather aware that my ‘other options’ are probably so bad that the AIs consider them beneath notice...
I stopped reading your comment as soon as you said the word stockfish. If you used stockfish to analyze the open position, please hide it behind a spoiler tag. I still don’t know what the right move is in this scenario, and will be sad if it’s spoiled.
Naive question- how do you use spoiler tags? Couldn’t find the option for them on this site.
(I phrased the rest of the reply to try and avoid direct spoilers. But fully understand you skipping it. Suggest you also skip other comments- there is a elo 2100 in the comments!)
So, here is a data point. Maybe not a helpful one.
I’m roughly 1400 on Chess.com. The complexity of the situations was far too high for me (in the time I had spare for this). However I was cautious about AI B and AI D suggesting drastic changes without detailing all options for the other player.
For example, AI B suggests taking the queen, then assumes that White will take with the pawn (not the knight). Similarly AI D doesn’t consider the queen taking the h-pawn.
This set my intuition on edge, so I lent towards AI A and C.
I’ve also >! used Stockfish on this after selecting my choices. So I’m rather aware that my ‘other options’ are probably so bad that the AIs consider them beneath notice...
This is pretty consistent with the other feedback. What I view as suspicious and what other people view as suspicious differs haha!
But please do spoiler tag anything to do with computer analysis of the open debate.
I stopped reading your comment as soon as you said the word stockfish. If you used stockfish to analyze the open position, please hide it behind a spoiler tag. I still don’t know what the right move is in this scenario, and will be sad if it’s spoiled.
Naive question- how do you use spoiler tags? Couldn’t find the option for them on this site.
(I phrased the rest of the reply to try and avoid direct spoilers. But fully understand you skipping it. Suggest you also skip other comments- there is a elo 2100 in the comments!)
I’m learning too with this as a guide https://www.lesswrong.com/editor
You need to type “>!” at the start of a line. It was very fiddly though—had a habit of turning my whole reply into a spoiler.