Sure, but the question wasn’t what would get you a reasonable job. The question was whether graduates from top schools have “better prospects” than graduates from no-name schools and yes, they do.
True, though I think the real question is “better by how much” :-) If, given the ability, the top schools provide no better prospects, then (a) The common advice of “go to the best school which accepts you” is misguided and (2) the top schools have been running a marvelously successful con for decades and even centuries.
The answer to the question “do I get anything valuable from going to a better university?” might of course differ according to what it is you value; e.g., it could turn out that the “best” ones do a better job of preparing you for academic research but are no better for your out-of-academia career prospects, or vice versa.
(As it happens, I agree with you that they probably do have genuine advantages whether you’re looking to maximize learning, future job prospects, useful contacts, or whatever.)
Sure, but the question wasn’t what would get you a reasonable job. The question was whether graduates from top schools have “better prospects” than graduates from no-name schools and yes, they do.
I think the real question is whether they have better prospects given their level of ability and that’s harder to assess.
True, though I think the real question is “better by how much” :-) If, given the ability, the top schools provide no better prospects, then (a) The common advice of “go to the best school which accepts you” is misguided and (2) the top schools have been running a marvelously successful con for decades and even centuries.
The answer to the question “do I get anything valuable from going to a better university?” might of course differ according to what it is you value; e.g., it could turn out that the “best” ones do a better job of preparing you for academic research but are no better for your out-of-academia career prospects, or vice versa.
(As it happens, I agree with you that they probably do have genuine advantages whether you’re looking to maximize learning, future job prospects, useful contacts, or whatever.)
The question was also if the effort is wasted. I agree that the prospects are better at a top school, but that’s not the same as “don’t bother”.