I notice myself wanting to vote on things I like, and being confused about whether to upvote or agree.
My guess at what’s happening: the part of me that forms an opinion is basically driven by status (reward good thought vs slap down bad thought) and I’ve tuned this well enough that it’s a good judge of quality. Two-axis karma forces me to go to system 2, which is sometimes good, but my system 1 is already pretty good at flagging things like “just because they disagree with you doesn’t mean they suck or you suck”.
I notice myself wanting to vote on things I like, and being confused about whether to upvote or agree.
My guess at what’s happening: the part of me that forms an opinion is basically driven by status (reward good thought vs slap down bad thought) and I’ve tuned this well enough that it’s a good judge of quality. Two-axis karma forces me to go to system 2, which is sometimes good, but my system 1 is already pretty good at flagging things like “just because they disagree with you doesn’t mean they suck or you suck”.
I’ll probably get used to it.