So is this discipline basically about ethics of imposing particular choices on other people (aka the “population”)? That makes it basically the ethics of power or ethics of the ruler(s).
That’s an interesting way to view it, but it seems accurate. Say God created the world, then contractualist ethics or ethics of cooperation didn’t apply to him, but we’d get a sense of what his population ethical stance must have been. No one ever gets asked whether they want to be born. This is one of the issues where there is no such thing as “not taking a stance;” how we act in our lifetimes is going to affect what sort of minds there will or won’t be in the far future. We can discuss suggestions and try to come to a consensus of those currently in power, but future generations are indeed in a powerless position.
how we act in our lifetimes is going to affect what sort of minds there will or won’t be in the far future
Sure, but so what? Your power to deliberately and purposefully affect these things is limited by your ability to understand and model the development of the world sufficiently well to know which levers to pull. I would like to suggest that for “far future” that power is indistinguishable from zero.
That’s an interesting way to view it, but it seems accurate. Say God created the world, then contractualist ethics or ethics of cooperation didn’t apply to him, but we’d get a sense of what his population ethical stance must have been.
No one ever gets asked whether they want to be born. This is one of the issues where there is no such thing as “not taking a stance;” how we act in our lifetimes is going to affect what sort of minds there will or won’t be in the far future. We can discuss suggestions and try to come to a consensus of those currently in power, but future generations are indeed in a powerless position.
Sure, but so what? Your power to deliberately and purposefully affect these things is limited by your ability to understand and model the development of the world sufficiently well to know which levers to pull. I would like to suggest that for “far future” that power is indistinguishable from zero.