“Workers regularly trade with billionaires and earn more than $77 in wages, despite vast differences in wealth.”
Yes, because the worker has something the billionaire wants (their labor) and so is able to sell it. Yudkowsky’s point about trying to sell an Oreo for $77 is that a billionaire isn’t automatically going to want to buy something off you if they don’t care about it (and neither would an ASI).
”I’m simply arguing against the point that smart AIs will automatically turn violent and steal from agents who are less smart than they are, unless they’re value aligned. This is a claim that I don’t think has been established with any reasonable degree of rigor.”
I completely agree but I’m not sure anyone is arguing that smart AIs would immediately turn violent unless it was in their strategic interest.
“Workers regularly trade with billionaires and earn more than $77 in wages, despite vast differences in wealth.”
Yes, because the worker has something the billionaire wants (their labor) and so is able to sell it. Yudkowsky’s point about trying to sell an Oreo for $77 is that a billionaire isn’t automatically going to want to buy something off you if they don’t care about it (and neither would an ASI).
”I’m simply arguing against the point that smart AIs will automatically turn violent and steal from agents who are less smart than they are, unless they’re value aligned. This is a claim that I don’t think has been established with any reasonable degree of rigor.”
I completely agree but I’m not sure anyone is arguing that smart AIs would immediately turn violent unless it was in their strategic interest.