I work for an hour and get paid $10, but whoever bought the fruits of my labor just killed $10 worth of people
They almost certainly would have anyway. I really don’t see why this matters. You’re (presumably) not trying to minimize aggregate sinfulness or anything like that, you’re trying to save lives. Therefore, you choose the action with the highest expected lives saved. It’s that simple.
They almost certainly would have anyway. I really don’t see why this matters. You’re (presumably) not trying to minimize aggregate sinfulness or anything like that, you’re trying to save lives. Therefore, you choose the action with the highest expected lives saved. It’s that simple.
The puzzle has nothing to do with lives saved. The puzzle has to do with assigning moral responsibility.
But elsewhere I figured out my missing piece.