Yeah, what you described indeed matches my notion of “values-on-reflection” pretty well. So for example, I think a religious person’s values-on-reflection should include valuing logical consistency and coherent logical arguments (because they do implicitly care about those in their everyday lives, even if they explicitly deny it). This means their values-on-reflection should include having true beliefs, and thus be atheistic. But I also wouldn’t generally trust religious people to update away from religion if they reflected a bunch.
Yeah, what you described indeed matches my notion of “values-on-reflection” pretty well. So for example, I think a religious person’s values-on-reflection should include valuing logical consistency and coherent logical arguments (because they do implicitly care about those in their everyday lives, even if they explicitly deny it). This means their values-on-reflection should include having true beliefs, and thus be atheistic. But I also wouldn’t generally trust religious people to update away from religion if they reflected a bunch.