I suspect the CFARians have more delicious cake for you, as I haven’t put that much time into circling, and the related connection skills I worked on more than a decade ago and have atrophied since.
Things I remember:
much quicker connection with people
there was a few things like exercise that I wasn’t passionate about but wanted to be. After talking with people who were passionate I was able to become passionate myself for those things
I was able to more quickly learn social cognitive strategies by interacting with others who had them.
To suggest something more concrete… would you predict that if an X-ist wanted to pass a Y-ist’s ITT, they would have more success if the two of them sat down to circle beforehand? Relative to doing nothing, and/or relative to other possible interventions like discussing X vs Y? For values of X and Y like Democrat/Republican, yay-SJ/boo-SJ, cat person/dog person, MIRI’s approach to AI/Paul Christiano’s approach?
It seems to me that (roughly speaking) if circling was more successful than other interventions, or successful on a wider range of topics, that would validate its utility. Said, do you agree?
I suspect the CFARians have more delicious cake for you, as I haven’t put that much time into circling, and the related connection skills I worked on more than a decade ago and have atrophied since.
Things I remember:
much quicker connection with people
there was a few things like exercise that I wasn’t passionate about but wanted to be. After talking with people who were passionate I was able to become passionate myself for those things
I was able to more quickly learn social cognitive strategies by interacting with others who had them.
To suggest something more concrete… would you predict that if an X-ist wanted to pass a Y-ist’s ITT, they would have more success if the two of them sat down to circle beforehand? Relative to doing nothing, and/or relative to other possible interventions like discussing X vs Y? For values of X and Y like Democrat/Republican, yay-SJ/boo-SJ, cat person/dog person, MIRI’s approach to AI/Paul Christiano’s approach?
It seems to me that (roughly speaking) if circling was more successful than other interventions, or successful on a wider range of topics, that would validate its utility. Said, do you agree?
Yes, although I expect the utility of circling over other methods to be dependent on the degree to which the ITT is based on intuitions.