The chief trick to making good mistakes is not hide them—especially not from yourself. Instead of turning away in denial when you make a mistake, you should become a connoisseur of your own mistakes, turning them over in your mind as if they were works of art, which in a way they are. The fundamental reaction to any mistake ought to be this: “Well, I won’t do that again!” Natural selection doesn’t actually think this thought; it just wipes out the goofers before they can reproduce; natural selection won’t do that again, at least not as often. Animals that can learn—learn not to make that noise, touch that wire, eat that food—have something with a similar selective force in their brains. We human beings carry matters to a much more swift and efficient level. We can actually think that thought, reflecting on what we have just done: “Well, I won’t do that again!” And when we reflect, we confront directly the problem that must be solved by any mistake-maker: what, exactly, is that? What was it about what I just did that got me into all this trouble? The trick is to take advantage of the particular details of the mess you’ve made, so that your next attempt will be informed by it and not just another blind stab in the dark.…
The natural human reaction to making a mistake is embarrassment and anger (we are never angrier than when are angry at ourselves), and you to work hard to overcome these emotional reactions. Try to acquire the weird practice of savoring your mistakes, delighting in uncovering the strange quirks that led you astray. Then once you have sucked out all the goodness to be gained from having made them, you can cheerfully set them behind you, and go on to the next big opportunity. But that this not enough; you should actively seek out opportunities to make grand mistakes; just so you can recover from them.
-Daniel Dennett, Intuition Pumps and Other Tools for Thinking
I didn’t read it that way—when I read “seek our opportunities to make grand mistakes”, the things I imagine are more like travel to foreign countries, try new things you’re bad at, talk to people way outside your usual circle, etc.
Not disagreeing, but “The natural human reaction to making a mistake is embarrassment and anger (we are never angrier than when are angry at ourselves)” is weird.
Why is the natural...anger?
Also, is that even true for everyone? I make mistakes all the time and don’t feel that, so I’m thinking he means “to publically taking a strong position and then being made to look like a fool”, which I certainly do feel. But maybe not?
If it’s not true for you then it isn’t true for everyone. But FWIW it’s somewhat true for me (though “anger” is a strong word). I get cross at how unreliable my brain is.
-Daniel Dennett, Intuition Pumps and Other Tools for Thinking
Think he’s a bit too enthusiastic about that X-D
Making more grand mistakes in addition to my usual number doesn’t look appealing to me :-/
I think he’s implicitly restricting himself to philosophy. A “grand mistake” in philosophy has little ill effects.
Um, they’ve been known to result in up to a quarter of the world’s population living under totalitarian dictatorships.
Fair enough. Good examples: Hegel --> Marx --> Soviet Union/China. Hegel --> Husserl --> Heidegger <---> Nazism.
I don’t know the context of the quote, but going just by the text quoted it doesn’t look like this.
That’s a pretty severe put-down of philosophy :-D
I didn’t read it that way—when I read “seek our opportunities to make grand mistakes”, the things I imagine are more like travel to foreign countries, try new things you’re bad at, talk to people way outside your usual circle, etc.
Not disagreeing, but “The natural human reaction to making a mistake is embarrassment and anger (we are never angrier than when are angry at ourselves)” is weird.
Why is the natural...anger?
Also, is that even true for everyone? I make mistakes all the time and don’t feel that, so I’m thinking he means “to publically taking a strong position and then being made to look like a fool”, which I certainly do feel. But maybe not?
If it’s not true for you then it isn’t true for everyone. But FWIW it’s somewhat true for me (though “anger” is a strong word). I get cross at how unreliable my brain is.