Given the disagreement with my comment, I seem to be in the minority, and I’m sure I’m digging deeper with this reply. I don’t think it just pattern-matches with politics, I think it’s primarily about politics. Replacing the examples with less-current ones, not just adding some decoys, would be necessary to fix it, IMO.
Or maybe not. “bodily autonomy” doesn’t seem like a coherent dimension to explore—it’s a mix of different things, most of which are interactions with others and with society, and combining them into this one idea seems politically motivated at it’s core.
I agree that the way it is right now pattern -matches with politics:
Short
Starts with a high-conflict position
Doesn’t (sufficiently) dissolve the question.
I think there should be more examples, not just Covid and abortion and more criteria. That should fix it.
Given the disagreement with my comment, I seem to be in the minority, and I’m sure I’m digging deeper with this reply. I don’t think it just pattern-matches with politics, I think it’s primarily about politics. Replacing the examples with less-current ones, not just adding some decoys, would be necessary to fix it, IMO.
Or maybe not. “bodily autonomy” doesn’t seem like a coherent dimension to explore—it’s a mix of different things, most of which are interactions with others and with society, and combining them into this one idea seems politically motivated at it’s core.